The economics of UHV lines in China is changing

Demand growth is shrinking and support for UHV lines weakening. The economics of existing UHV lines has been poorer than expected and this is further reducing enthusiasm for expansion, according to The Lantau Group research.

NEA assesses Provincial Power Surplus Rate in 2015 


Three key points are summarized below:

(1) As of March 2017, China’s UHV network stretched across 18,000km; a further seven projects currently under construction will extend this out to 30,000km.

Bottomline: The 13th Five Year Plan has overseen a major expansion of the network, but the grid still lags original plans.

(2) The recent apparent pause in further UHV approvals reflects several factors.

  • First, the technical challenge of interconnecting China’s vast power system cannot be underestimated. 
  • Second, UHV expansion is likely producing less benefit than originally expected due to slowing growth in electricity consumption and the near ubiquitous problem of overcapacity. 
Bottomline: Finding a suitable province that can receive surplus power has become harder as almost all provinces now have some degree of oversupply or prefer to build their own capacity to meet expected future demand in order to retain both tax revenue and employment opportunities. 

Ambitious renewable targets have only exacerbated this oversupply.


TLG provides Changes in Generation by Fuel Types from 2016 to 2020


(3) Development plans for coal, hydro and renewable capacity additions all affect the prospects for new UHV projects. While Sichuan and Yunnan provinces are both capable of substantial hydro additions, there appears to have been little appetite to approve new UHV lines out of these provinces. At least part of the problem lies in poor national and regional coordination. Power planning lies with different levels of authorities, and this exacerbates the problems of coordinating successful inter-provincial power flows as each province independently seeks to build out its own new capacity, reducing any need for power imports or the UHV lines that would carry it.

Bottomline: The cancellation of new coal capacity will likely delay associated UHV projects while renewable generation capacity may not be reliable enough to support UHV lines unaided. 

More at HVDC Belt and Road 2019 China Conference

Comments